Birmingham, Ala. – Today the Alabama Policy Institute (API) submitted to the Governor’s Special Task Force on Reopening the Economy a report (“Healthy Citizenry, Healthy Economy, Healthy Society”) detailing two important factors related to returning to normalcy after the COVID-19 pandemic. In response to a request from Senate President Pro tempore Del Marsh, a member of the task force’s executive committee, API considered the impact of the shutdown on civil liberties and the Alabama Department of Labor’s response to the economic downturn. Phil Williams, API’s Director of Policy Strategy and General Counsel who serves on the task force, delivered the report today.

“As the leading non-profit, non-partisan authority on good public policy in Alabama, API is honored to have a seat at the table during discussions on how best to move toward a post-pandemic sense of normalcy,” said API President Caleb Crosby. “Decisions to reopen society must be based on facts, data, and be grounded in the protection of personal freedom and liberty; API’s recommendations to the Governor’s Special Task Force do just that.”

First, the report asserts that government control, such as those directives which led to the shutdown of the economy and society, must not become a “new normal,” and the default position should always be from a liberty-first perspective. API asserts, though the governor has “certain limited discretionary powers” to create regulations and suspend laws during a time of declared emergency, a continued use of those powers could lead to litigation over constitutional violations. The report identifies five areas in which constitutional rights may be violated if the current emergency orders remain in place much longer (see page two of the report).

Instead of operating from the default position that the government must always act and do so without limit, the goal of opening society must start with the premise that liberty should be protected, and the government must only act when absolutely necessary. “The State of Alabama has responsibilities in controlling the pandemic and in reopening society, but government action must never become more important than the free exercise of constitutionally protected rights and freedoms,” said Williams.

Second, the report addresses the unintended consequences of increased unemployment benefits which include a state benefit of $275 per week and a new federal benefit of $600 per week for up to 39 weeks, an increase from the previous limit of 14 to 20 weeks, set by the State Legislature. Now, a recipient is no longer required to have been terminated, but only must not be working due to the impact of COVID-19. Based on research and conclusions drawn in the report, API recommends the Alabama Department of Labor (ADOL) do more to limit fraud and abuse of the new benefits and should use its regulatory discretion to ensure that the new benefits (an effective hourly rate of $21.87) don’t have an adverse effect of causing individuals to refrain from returning to work, or quitting if they are working, because the benefits are more than normal wages.

“It is not unimaginable that a worker at an essential business such as a grocery store, 1) sees that they can make more money on unemployment, 2) claims that they quit because they felt unsafe at work because of COVID-19, and 3) gains approval and receives three times the income they would have had if they continued working” the report suggests. Such a scenario could also negatively affect businesses which received forgivable loans under the federal CARES Act, as they might have to repay the loan if their payroll decreases due to employees quitting in order to receive unemployment compensation. API’s research also concludes the ADOL’s increase of benefit weeks, which is set by state law, cannot be legally sustained as an increase in weeks must be changed by an act of the State Legislature (see page 14 of the report). In effect, “ADOL is currently ‘encouraging’ applications for benefits” rather than trying to ensure only those who really need unemployment dollars receive them.

“It simply doesn’t make sense for the Alabama Department of Labor to promulgate rules and regulations which encourage unemployment and discourage people from working,” remarked Williams of API and the task force executive committee. “People who really need help should get it, no question; but we should not allow an increase in benefits to become a gateway toward long-term dependence on compensation from the government.”

In all, the report includes nine recommendations for actions to be taken by various individuals or entities, including the Governor’s Special Task Force, ADOL, and the State Legislature (see page three of the report). Specifically, among others, the report recommends the task force become a working, “daily living entity … with the sole focus of synthesizing and synchronizing the way forward to reopen” society. The recommendations also call for a special legislative session to enact legislation “that provides protections/indemnity to businesses and local governments who face claims of liability related to the COVID-19 pandemic and the government shutdown” as well as the passage of laws to prevent unemployment fraud and abuse and incentives to encourage business investment.

“We need to take whatever steps are necessary to ensure the government’s response to COVID-19 does not become a new normal by getting on a path toward returning to pre-pandemic normalcy,” concluded API’s Chief Operating Officer Carl Jones. “We have a responsibility to ensure this crisis, and society’s and government’s response to it, does not allow for an increased reliance on the government, the expansion of government powers, or the trampling of any citizen’s liberty and individual rights and responsibilities.”

A PDF version of the full report can be accessed at here.

The Alabama Policy Institute is an independent, nonpartisan, nonprofit research and educational organization dedicated to free markets, limited government, and strong families, learn more at www.alabamapolicy.org

 

# # #


MORE ON Economic Freedom

Keep a Weather Eye on the Horizon – A Legal Storm is Brewing

I don’t know if you’ve ever had the displeasure of being at sea when a major storm develops. It is disconcerting, to say the least. As the deck pitches and rolls, the mental review of the all-hands disaster planning takes place in the mind. Pulling into a safe harbor and putting feet on dry land […]

Alabama Needs to Limit Uncertainty for Healthcare Providers in the Pandemic

Uncertainty can be crippling. In many, it turns an energetic “can-do” spirit into a cautious “wait and see” mentality. In 2011, more than half of small businesses surveyed by the US Chamber of Commerce said they were holding off on hiring new employees largely because of uncertainty about the economy. That was in 2011. What […]

The RESTORE Alabama Agenda

Read the full RESTORE Plan here. The 2020 Regular Session of the Alabama State Legislature is behind us. Did anyone notice? It was a Session marked more by what didn’t happen than by what did. One minute the lobbyists were being paid well to try and get marijuana legalized, state budgets were flush, and gambling […]

MORE ON Education

This Back To School Season, Families Should Decide

Parents and other observers have many understandable questions about how their local school districts are responding to the challenges presented by COVID-19. At this juncture, I don’t think it’s helpful to lay much blame on anyone. There will be plenty of time for that in the future, and when the dust settles, we’re likely to […]

API President’s Statement Opposing Governor’s “Masks in Class” Mandate

Birmingham, Ala. – Today (July 29, 2020), Alabama Policy Institute President Caleb Crosby released the following statement in response to Governor Kay Ivey’s amended “Safer at Home Order” that purports to require masks in Alabama classrooms. “Governor Ivey’s ‘masks in class’ order goes too far, is unenforceable, and burdensome to the students and teachers of our […]

To Educate Our Children

Children often bear the worst of our challenges, and our disagreements. When Alabama public schools shut down in response to the Coronavirus pandemic, we saw (again) that the promise of education is not equally available to all young people. Many government-run school administrators were unable to deliver education to the children within their districts. At […]

MORE ON Family

MOBILE RADIO: Supreme Court Redefines “Sex”

API director of policy analysis Parker Snider recently appeared on Mobile Radio to discuss the Supreme Court’s recent redefinition of “sex” to include gender identity and sexual orientation through its ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, Georgia. You can listen to the interview here beginning at the 44:35 timestamp. LA Catholic Mornings, Archangel Radio Mobile […]

Philosopher Kings on the Supreme Court Usurp Congress and the People. Again.

According to ancient Greek philosopher Plato, it is the great thinkers, or philosophers, who are best suited to govern society. Dubbed “philosopher kings” they use wisdom, Plato says, to determine how society should operate. Ours is not a country governed by philosopher kings. The Founding Fathers, instead, predicated our government as one of the people. […]

Balancing Rights and Love of Neighbor

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey has announced that our state is moving into an initial phase of economic recovery, known as “Safer at Home.” It relaxes restrictions on many businesses while keeping others, like restaurants, heavily limited for now. The hope is that all businesses will be allowed to resume a modified type of operation shortly. […]

MORE ON Fiscal Policy

For Whom the Bridge Tolls

If you’ve followed the news lately you could not have missed the fact that there has been a kerfluffle of the highest order near the Alabama coastline. Like a scene from the old fairy tale, the Three Billy Goats Gruff, the local populace has thrown the “bridge trolls” into the bay and seemingly defeated the infamous toll payments that were at issue. The difference between our coastal brethren and sistren and the Goats is that the Goats got a bridge out of it.

Statewide Radio: Phil Williams on Viewpoint Alabama

API director of policy strategy Phil Williams recently appeared on Viewpoint Alabama, a weekly radio show that is broadcast on over 60 Alabama radio stations, to discuss the potential toll bridge in Mobile, the increase in the gas tax, and more. You can listen to the interview here (beginning at the 0:30 timestamp). Viewpoint Alabama, […]

MORE ON Good Governance

Hey, ABC Board…Know Your Role!

Let’s start with clearing the air…generally speaking I don’t hang out in bars. This is not a puff piece to defend pub crawls. So before any of my folks, fans or friends think that I’m writing this because I was hoping for one last round after 11 p.m., the answer is “no”. What I do […]

Phil Williams Discusses “Masks in Class” Mandate on Evening News

Phil Williams, Director of Policy Strategy for the Alabama Policy Institute, recently discussed Governor Ivey’s “Masks in Class” mandate on  WSFA Montgomery’s evening news program. To watch, click here. To keep up with API, sign-up for our newsletter at alabamapolicy.com/subscribe  

Keep a Weather Eye on the Horizon – A Legal Storm is Brewing

I don’t know if you’ve ever had the displeasure of being at sea when a major storm develops. It is disconcerting, to say the least. As the deck pitches and rolls, the mental review of the all-hands disaster planning takes place in the mind. Pulling into a safe harbor and putting feet on dry land […]

MORE FROM Phil Williams

Mobile Radio: Phil Williams on Midday Mobile with Sean Sullivan

Last Friday, API’s Director of Policy Strategy and General Counsel Phil Williams joined Sean Sullivan on Midday Mobile on FM 106.5. In the segment, Sullivan and Williams discuss the Alcoholic Beverage Control Board’s recent decision to ban alcohol sales after 11 p.m. To listen, click here (timestamp 9:14).

Hey, ABC Board…Know Your Role!

Let’s start with clearing the air…generally speaking I don’t hang out in bars. This is not a puff piece to defend pub crawls. So before any of my folks, fans or friends think that I’m writing this because I was hoping for one last round after 11 p.m., the answer is “no”. What I do […]

Mobile Radio: Phil Williams on the Jeff Poor Show

This Thursday, API’s Director of Policy Strategy and General Counsel Phil Williams joined the Jeff Poor Show. In the 20-minute segment, Poor and Williams discuss the “masks in class” mandate, rolling back government overreach, and more. To listen, click here.