By Dana Hall McCain

Americans experienced yet another sex scandal involving an elected leader in recent weeks, culminating in the resignation of freshman Congressman Katie Hill of California. Nude photos were published depicting Hill in a polyamorous, bisexual relationship with her now-estranged husband and a campaign staffer. Additional allegations have surfaced of a more recent affair with her legislative director, a male. Hill has admitted to the affair with the campaign staffer but denies the one with her current staff member.

It’s funny how circumstances often dictate the way we apply certain standards.

For a few years now, the Me Too movement has worked to educate us about the unethical nature of sexual relationships between employers and employees. They’ve trained us to understand the problems inherent within such a power imbalance, corrupting the normal, healthy freedoms of a relationship between consenting adults. They’ve preached that any romantic interaction with a subordinate is workplace sexual harassment, period.

Now that a progressive politician is caught in the snare of this standard, however, there’s a need to blame her fall on something else.

One way in which Hill’s supporters have cried foul on her resignation is to point out that fellow California Congressman Duncan Hunter is still seated and seeking re-election despite being indicted for campaign finance crimes, including alleged illegal expenditures for extramarital flings with lobbyists and others. They say that Hill is being held to a higher standard than Hunter and that it’s evidence of a misogynistic double-standard.

To be clear, if the allegations against Hunter are true, he should be resigning as well—today. But the thing that is buying him time to slow-walk what I think will ultimately be his demise (either at the polls or in court) is that America hasn’t seen photos of him engaged in the very thing he is accused of.

Photos are like jet fuel to a scandal. It covers the distance between wild allegation and credible charges in a nanosecond.
Not only did Hill engage in what most Americans view as an unethical and immoral sexual relationship, but she also allowed herself to be photographed in the nude, in intimate moments that leave no doubt about the nature of the relationship.

Hear me out: revenge porn publication is just as unethical and disturbing as the acts they seek to uncover and weaponize. It’s gross. But the reason Katie Hill felt compelled to quickly resign, and that Duncan Hunter is taking his sweet time, is that the existence of nude photos of her (in the hands of someone who doesn’t mind sharing them) paint her into a much tighter corner than Hunter.

That’s not the culture’s fault.

No one forced Katie Hill to take part in polyamorous sexual relationships. No one forced Katie Hill to engage in an unethical relationship with a young (22) campaign staffer. And no one forced Katie Hill to smile for a camera, clutching a filthy bong, while she was living her life this way. Those are all her choices.

And now that Americans—including voters in her district—have seen these things, they naturally factor into whether we believe her when she denies the more recent affair with a member of her congressional staff, which if true constitutes a clear violation of House rules. Her credibility as a person who lives inside the lines of sexual ethics in the workplace is shot. Thus, her ability to serve her constituents is severely compromised.

I realize that many Americans no longer share my Christian view of sexual morality, or believe that personal moral standards have bearing on a person’s fitness to lead. (And for the record, I believe that personal character is essential for every leader from the White House to the neighborhood watch committee, and give no quarter based on party affiliation.) Many will say that it’s none of our business if Hill is into polyamory, or is bisexual. But when she crosses the sexual ethics lines that progressives have themselves drawn, it has to be game over.

So kids, here’s what we’ve learned. Want to protect yourself from revenge porn attacks?

1. Don’t star in (public or private) porn;
2. With a spouse with whom you have a rocky “open” relationship;
3. While at the same time aspiring to a life of public service;
4. In 2019, where digital images are never really dead.

Statistically speaking, this has a high probability of ending badly.

Life is a series of choices, and all choices have consequences.

Forgive me if I don’t waste a lot of time grieving the fact that Katie Hill’s litany of poor choices boxed her into a final choice—resigning from Congress—that tasted bitter going down.

Dana Hall McCain, a widely published writer on faith, culture, and politics, is Resident Fellow of the Alabama Policy Institute, alabamapolicy.org.


MORE ON API in the Editorials

It’s Not Personal

One of the cultural problems we have today is our insistence on making everything personal. We can no longer discuss and debate ideas without someone assuming that disagreement is tantamount to a personal attack. Our skin is so thin it’s transparent. Take last week, for example. In the run-up to Super Tuesday, Alabamians were debating […]

Female Athletes Deserve Fair Competition

Silly me. I thought that with the passage of Title IX of the Education Amendment Act of 1972, we had settled the question of whether girls deserve a chance to compete and win as high school and college athletes. Feminists fought like warriors to pass the act against gender discrimination, which among other things ensured […]

It’s Time for Prison, Mental Health Reform

Two of the major items on Governor Kay Ivey’s 2020 agenda are finding solutions to the problem of Alabama’s overcrowded and broken prison system, and bolstering our mental healthcare system. Both are badly needed, and in some ways intersect. I understand the political challenge of getting folks excited about funding a major overhaul of something […]

MORE ON Family

Preventing death by allowing ‘essential’ murder

We live in wild times. I’ve watched people all across the political spectrum in recent days deliver impassioned speeches about the need to take extraordinary measures to preserve human life. They say they believe the elderly and vulnerable are just as deserving of a chance to live as any other. They are right. Human life […]

Pro-Life in a Pandemic

For those of us who are pro-life, it’s easy to get in the habit of only thinking of this pillar of our values system in the context of abortion. But occasionally a crisis comes along to remind us that a biblical view of human life has far broader applications. Such is the case with COVID-19. […]

Female Athletes Deserve Fair Competition

Silly me. I thought that with the passage of Title IX of the Education Amendment Act of 1972, we had settled the question of whether girls deserve a chance to compete and win as high school and college athletes. Feminists fought like warriors to pass the act against gender discrimination, which among other things ensured […]

MORE ON Good Governance

Exclusive: Senate Pro Tem Del Marsh Comments on COVID-19’s impact on Alabama, State Budgets, Prisons, and more

Birmingham, Ala. – Today the Alabama Policy Institute released an interview with Alabama Senate Pro tempore, Del Marsh through its 1819 Podcast (along with a full transcript). The interview covers Alabama’s COVID-19 response and reveals Senator Marsh’s thoughts on state budgets, prison reform, the legislative session and more. Regarding COVID-19, Senator Marsh details asking State Health Officer […]

Success in coronavirus response must be defined and coordinated

Isn’t it amazing to see the grandstanders who show up in a crisis that have the luxury of not having to own a plan? I’ve heard a bevy of pundits and those not actually in charge of anything (elected and unelected) shouting that the sky is falling. None of them have offered a solution other […]

MORE FROM Dana Hall McCain

Preventing death by allowing ‘essential’ murder

We live in wild times. I’ve watched people all across the political spectrum in recent days deliver impassioned speeches about the need to take extraordinary measures to preserve human life. They say they believe the elderly and vulnerable are just as deserving of a chance to live as any other. They are right. Human life […]

Pro-Life in a Pandemic

For those of us who are pro-life, it’s easy to get in the habit of only thinking of this pillar of our values system in the context of abortion. But occasionally a crisis comes along to remind us that a biblical view of human life has far broader applications. Such is the case with COVID-19. […]

It’s Not Personal

One of the cultural problems we have today is our insistence on making everything personal. We can no longer discuss and debate ideas without someone assuming that disagreement is tantamount to a personal attack. Our skin is so thin it’s transparent. Take last week, for example. In the run-up to Super Tuesday, Alabamians were debating […]