Illinois-lottery-winners-cant-get-money“Which is the most immoral,” Governor Robert Bentley mused philosophically to the press last week, “buying five lottery tickets with money you earned or allowing a child to die?” A state lottery in Alabama is “the only real choice,” he warned ominously. “There is no plan B.”

Governor Bentley was making an extremely serious argument, to wit: children would die if Alabama did not approve a state lottery. The argument is of such seriousness that one would assume he had scrupulously studied the numbers to arrive at such a dire determination.

And, indeed, Governor Bentley has adumbrated as much through his confident pronouncements about a state lottery to the people of Alabama. “The time has come for us to find a permanent solution,” he stated in his remarks announcing the 2016 Special Session, explaining that a lottery could “provide funding that we can count on year after year.” The revenue that he said would result was astounding. “An Alabama lottery,” he claimed, “is expected to generate approximately $225 million annually.” Even more astounding, he said that the amount was merely the minimum—an intentional underestimation on his part, reflecting his fiscal prudence. “We wanted to put a low number in there to begin with,” Governor Bentley explained, “but we feel like that it will generate at least that amount.” He declared that his lottery proposal would prove “a means through which we can get $225 million to $300 million” per year.

There was, however, an unanswered question. “How did you determine $225 million?” a reporter finally asked late last week. Governor Bentley’s answer was revelatory: “Actually, my, uh, Executive Business [sic] Office, uh, worked, uh, on this. They looked at other states our size.” Those two sentences are, in fact, an accurate précis to how the determination was made.

The methodology underlying the $225 million calculation can be described in a single sentence. The Executive Budget Office picked four states—Arkansas, Louisiana, Kentucky, and South Carolina—averaged the per-capita lottery revenue of those four states, and multiplied that average by the population of Alabama. Yet, those four states are not all that comparable to Alabama, aside from having similar per-capita personal incomes—which tells us how much money people have to spend, but not what they are likely to spend it on (e.g., Alabama and Louisiana might only be separated by one state, but each is worlds apart in myriad ways)—and they certainly are not the most comparable states to Alabama out of others that could have been chosen. The calculation is unsophisticated, unreliable, and untruthful as employed by Governor Bentley.

We can, therefore, make short work of both of Governor Bentley’s claims. First, his claim that a lottery would be a “permanent solution” to the state’s budget problems by bringing in “at least” $225 million is conclusively false. No reasonable person could have honestly made those declarations based on a mere one year of data from a mere four states. Second, his claim that children would die unless a lottery were approved is manifestly false. No reasonable person who truly believes that human lives hang in the balance would be so reckless as to not be thorough in studying whether a lottery would actually bring in the revenue necessary to save those lives.

Both claims are, in short, sophistry.

A version of this essay first appeared in print on August 19, 2016, on page 23 of the Birmingham Business Journal, available online at http://www.bizjournals.com/birmingham/news/2016/08/19/looking-at-the-lottery-math.html.


MORE ON API in the Editorials

Has the Magic City Become the Tragic City?

Leadership matters. The tone and tenor of a policy are often the reflection of the leader who presided over the period in which that policy took effect. And leadership matters the most, becomes most visible, and is looked to by others more often when crisis looms. Noted author and lecturer Victor Davis Hanson said that […]

The Need for Education Reform Didn’t Die with the Defeat of Amendment One

When voters defeat a proposed state amendment, it is often thought that the matter is put to rest. That is often the case, but when Alabama’s voters went to the polls in March and shot down a proposal to replace the elected state board of education in favor of one appointed by the governor, they […]

Balancing Rights and Love of Neighbor

Alabama Governor Kay Ivey has announced that our state is moving into an initial phase of economic recovery, known as “Safer at Home.” It relaxes restrictions on many businesses while keeping others, like restaurants, heavily limited for now. The hope is that all businesses will be allowed to resume a modified type of operation shortly. […]

MORE ON Fiscal Policy

Alabama Policy Institute Submits Report to the Governor’s Special Task Force on Reopening the Economy, highlights Constitutional Freedom, and the Role of the Alabama Department of Labor

Birmingham, Ala. – Today the Alabama Policy Institute (API) submitted to the Governor’s Special Task Force on Reopening the Economy a report (“Healthy Citizenry, Healthy Economy, Healthy Society”) detailing two important factors related to returning to normalcy after the COVID-19 pandemic. In response to a request from Senate President Pro tempore Del Marsh, a member […]

For Whom the Bridge Tolls

If you’ve followed the news lately you could not have missed the fact that there has been a kerfluffle of the highest order near the Alabama coastline. Like a scene from the old fairy tale, the Three Billy Goats Gruff, the local populace has thrown the “bridge trolls” into the bay and seemingly defeated the infamous toll payments that were at issue. The difference between our coastal brethren and sistren and the Goats is that the Goats got a bridge out of it.

MORE ON Lottery and Gambling

If the People Only Knew

“The people want to vote!”—the most oft-repeated catchphrase of the lottery debate. Even politicians who declare themselves personally opposed to a state-run lottery try to justify their support of it because “the people want to vote.” But politicians know full well that they have not been honest with the people when it comes to a […]

Republicans’ Proposal a Bad Move for Alabama

We have known for months that a deal was in the works to expand gambling operations in Alabama either through a lottery, a tribal compact, or privately run casinos. This move under Republican leadership is disheartening, but not surprising. Any chance at a money grab, be it through tax increases or gambling, is far easier […]

State Lotteries and the Government’s Betrayal of the Poor

A lot has changed since 1890 when President Benjamin Harrison reminded citizens that lotteries “debauched and defrauded” the public. Today, however, state governments have become the biggest proponents of lotteries. In fact, forty-four states have succumbed to the pressure to enact lotteries.  Hoping to fill a $200 million-plus budget shortfall, there is once again a […]

MORE FROM Andrew A. Yerbey

An Appreciation of Appreciations

A Torch Kept Lit: Great Lives of the Twentieth Century By William F. Buckley Jr. Edited by James Rosen (Crown Forum, 357 pages, $22) Had there never been a William F. Buckley Jr., American conservatism would look very different—and so might the world. “All great biblical stories begin with Genesis,” George Will wrote in the […]

License to Kill Opportunity

In Alabama, we expect—quite rightly—our fellow citizens to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps. But what if there is a barrier between citizens and their boots, blocking them from reaching the straps? And what if that barrier is unwarranted, put there by the state without good reason? The answer, of course, is that this […]

Diplomas of Duplicity, Revisited

“That’s one of the things that gives me a great peace about leaving.” So spoke Tommy Bice, Alabama’s outgoing superintendent of education, about the graduation rate of public-school students in our state on a recent appearance on Alabama Public Television’s Capitol Journal. That something which should induce nightmares is being spun as imparting “great peace” […]