Supporters of expanding gambling in Alabama often hype the opportunities missed by our state to “keep Alabama gambling dollars in Alabama.”  Given the economic and social damage that
would come with establishing a compact with the Poarch Creek Indians, our state government—especially under conservative leadership—should not be involved in this sordid business.

The only reason the state is flirting with a compact is because there’s money to be made—up to $60 million to help plug a $200 million hole in the state’s 2015 budget. This possibility of new revenue should not be considered with blinders on as to the repercussions that can come with it.  Gambling damages almost everything it touches.  From increased crime rates, to addictions that last for years, to personal debt and bankruptcy, gambling is a scourge to any community that embraces it with the hope of making a fast buck.

Gambling is more than just a personal vice that affects only the individual who chooses to do it; it is an economic injustice that Alabamians of all political leanings should oppose.  It teases the poor with the illusion of wealth.  The jobs that typically come with gambling tend to be low-wage positions that, in places where casinos have closed because of falling demand, are short-lived.  In the past year, for example, two casinos in Mississippi have closed.  In Atlantic City, New Jersey, four casinos have closed or will close soon, including its newest one, the $2.4 billion Revel.  Thousands of workers in both states who thought that gambling would be their ticket to success have been laid off.

Having the state involved in large-scale gambling solely for short-term economic gain is contrary to the principle of limited government.  If Alabama is fiscally desperate enough to establish a compact with the Poarch Creeks Indians, additional government offices will have to be created to manage it.  This new arm of government would be established with the sole purpose of keeping itself in existence by ensuring that casino gambling dollars flow into the state’s coffers.  Alabama’s conservative leadership will find itself facing a powerful successor to the now-diminished AEA, an organization that will increase in power and influence using the money lost by our own state’s gamblers.  Make no mistake: with the American gambling market saturated, the only people visiting Alabama’s casinos will be Alabamians, especially its poorest.  Why would any state’s leadership wish these problems on its populace?

Grasping for revenue that will do long-term damage by cannibalizing local economies is not a responsible approach to the current shortfall.  Embracing gambling in return for a quick payoff puts the state in the position of trying to put a dollar value on the health and well-being of the citizens who would be hurt by it.

Alabama has a long history of its citizens wisely rejecting calls to expand gambling in the state because we’ve seen the human toll of what it can do in other states like Mississippi and Louisiana.  Governor Bentley appears to have made the decision not to pursue the expansion of gambling in the state as a possible fix to the state’s General Fund shortfall.  The remainder of Alabama’s leaders should follow suit and consider instead sustainable budget solutions that don’t wreck our state and exact a toll on “the least of these.”

Dr. John Hill is senior research analyst for the Alabama Policy Institute (API), an independent non-partisan, non-profit research and education organization dedicated to the preservation of free markets, limited government and strong families. If you would like to speak with the author, please email or call (205) 870-9900.

MORE ON API in the Editorials

It’s Not Personal

One of the cultural problems we have today is our insistence on making everything personal. We can no longer discuss and debate ideas without someone assuming that disagreement is tantamount to a personal attack. Our skin is so thin it’s transparent. Take last week, for example. In the run-up to Super Tuesday, Alabamians were debating […]

Female Athletes Deserve Fair Competition

Silly me. I thought that with the passage of Title IX of the Education Amendment Act of 1972, we had settled the question of whether girls deserve a chance to compete and win as high school and college athletes. Feminists fought like warriors to pass the act against gender discrimination, which among other things ensured […]

It’s Time for Prison, Mental Health Reform

Two of the major items on Governor Kay Ivey’s 2020 agenda are finding solutions to the problem of Alabama’s overcrowded and broken prison system, and bolstering our mental healthcare system. Both are badly needed, and in some ways intersect. I understand the political challenge of getting folks excited about funding a major overhaul of something […]

MORE ON Lottery and Gambling

If the People Only Knew

“The people want to vote!”—the most oft-repeated catchphrase of the lottery debate. Even politicians who declare themselves personally opposed to a state-run lottery try to justify their support of it because “the people want to vote.” But politicians know full well that they have not been honest with the people when it comes to a […]

Looking at the Lottery Math

“Which is the most immoral,” Governor Robert Bentley mused philosophically to the press last week, “buying five lottery tickets with money you earned or allowing a child to die?” A state lottery in Alabama is “the only real choice,” he warned ominously. “There is no plan B.” Governor Bentley was making an extremely serious argument, to […]

Republicans’ Proposal a Bad Move for Alabama

We have known for months that a deal was in the works to expand gambling operations in Alabama either through a lottery, a tribal compact, or privately run casinos. This move under Republican leadership is disheartening, but not surprising. Any chance at a money grab, be it through tax increases or gambling, is far easier […]

MORE FROM John Hill, Ph.D.

New NAEP Scores Show No Link Between Education Spending and Academic Outcomes

In the Alabama State House, the familiar refrain surrounding public education is that the legislature has failed to ever “fully fund” it. The implication, of course, is that we cannot and should not expect positive outcomes from our public schools. This philosophy has been refuted by an enormous body of academic research and, last week, […]

The Coming Storm in ACA Implementation

Had the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against the poorly-named Affordable Care Act in King v. Burwell, almost 500,000 Alabamians could have been spared the cost of the program’s individual mandate.  Premiums for a healthy 21-year-old would have dropped by almost seven hundred dollars a year, and by more than two thousand dollars annually for a […]

Better Late than Never: Time to Legalize Charter Schools in Alabama

Since 1992, public charter schools have offered families in other states a choice when it comes to which public school their children can attend. Charter schools are public schools that are publicly funded, tuition-free, and must enroll any student who wishes to attend as long as there is capacity for them. They are authorized through […]