gavelOn Wednesday, the U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari in the case of Lynch v. Alabama, which simply means the Court refused to overturn the decision of the federal judge in Birmingham and the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta.  Filed in 2011 by plaintiffs representing public schoolchildren in Lawrence and Sumter counties, the lawsuit sought to nullify provisions of Alabama’s Constitution related to property taxes. The plaintiffs argued that the property tax structure was originally designed with the intent to discriminate against predominantly black school districts, such as the ones in these two counties, and should therefore be declared unconstitutional.

The plaintiffs argument centered on two particular elements of Alabama’s property tax structure—the classes of property and the caps on millage. Alabama’s property tax system is divided into four classes each having a specified assessment ratio: private passenger automobiles used only for private use (Class IV- 15% assessment); all agriculture, forest, and single family owner occupied residential property (Class III- 10% assessment); all property not otherwise classified (Class II- 20% assessment); and property of utilities used for utility business (Class I- 30% assessment).  The ratios mean that these classes of properties are not taxed at their total fair market value, but only on the percentage of value assigned to the class.  As was noted by an expert witness for the State, similar classification systems are used by a large number of states in the country.

Sections 214-216 of the Alabama Constitution place a cap on the property tax rate (the millage) that the legislature, counties, and localities can levy.  Local school systems are permitted to levy up to an aggregate of 15.0 mills in property taxes for educational purposes, through a combination of county and school district taxes.  Increasing property taxes up to this maximum is done only through referendum by voters in the county.  One of most striking points made by the 11th Circuit is that voters in the two counties represented by the plaintiffs have repeatedly “rejected various proposals to increase property taxes.” Thus, both counties already tax property below the approved maximum.  Knowing this, the plaintiffs sought to use the courts to force an outcome that the local citizenry did not prioritize.  While the plaintiffs claimed that caps on millage “crippled” the schools from raising revenue, their frustration should really be directed towards the voters in their own counties.

While the plaintiffs claimed that caps on millage “crippled” the schools from raising revenue, their frustration should really be directed towards the voters in their own counties.

The plaintiffs sought to have the court declare both the property tax classes and the caps unconstitutional under the premise that these constitutional amendments were adopted in a time of racial turmoil in Alabama’s history and were therefore passed with the intention of discriminating against black schools.  In other words, because land and timber owners pay a lower property tax rate than ordinary property owners, schools in rural counties with large, privately-held tracts of land receive few property tax dollars, leading to worse outcomes for their students.

Plaintiffs and other opponents of Alabama’s property tax structure maintain that the class III assessment ratio serves to benefit wealthy land and timber owners to the detriment of their low-income neighbors. This overlooks the fact that residential property is in this same class. In a predominantly black county like Sumter, it can be reasonably assumed that minority landowners fully benefit from this reduced taxation. Furthermore, even if there were no minority landowners in Sumter County, it cannot be reasonably argued that white people alone voted down past increases when the county is 75% black. The inverse would be true in Lawrence County.

There is a reason that Alabama has one of the nation’s lowest property tax burden- citizens have shown their preference for a low property tax burden by repeatedly rejecting increases, no different than voters in Lawrence and Sumter counties have.  Property owners oppose increases either because they can’t afford to pay more or because they are not convinced that the local school district will use the increased funds efficiently or in ways that will actually benefit the students—or both.  A community’s willingness to pay higher taxes for the benefit of their schools is directly tied to the citizens’ level of engagement and involvement in the schools.  Increased funding without this engagement is rarely going to solve an underperforming school’s woes.  If the plaintiffs’ suit had been successful, provisions of the tax structure highly valued by the landowners of their counties would have been disposed of without any semblance of a guarantee that their schools would improve in return.

Katherine Robertson is vice president  for the Alabama Policy Institute (API), an independent non-partisan, non-profit research and education organization dedicated to the preservation of free markets, limited government and strong families. If you would like to speak with the author, please email or call (205) 870-9900.

Note: This column is a copyrighted feature distributed free of charge by the Alabama Policy Institute. Permission to reprint in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author and API are properly cited. 



Legislative Session: Week 5 Review

It was a slower week, so before you kick off your weekend, check out what happened in Montgomery during week five of the 2018 legislative session! By the way, if you want to receive daily news hits from across the state and nation straight to your inbox each morning, click here to subscribe to API’s Daily […]

Using our tax breaks and bonuses for things that matter

“Crumbs”. That’s how House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi characterized the thousand-dollar bonuses and wage increases that companies are offering employees in the wake of federal tax reform. This description has, appropriately, come under attack. Walmart, Alabama’s largest employer, is spending around $400 million on employee bonuses. In fact, according to Americans for Tax Reform, over […]

Calling All Candidates: Let’s Talk Education

You spoke, Alabama. We asked, what issues are important to you and what questions would you ask of your candidates to answer?  Since last week was National School Choice Week, let’s explore questions on promoting education and supporting Alabama’s school children. And it probably won’t come as much of a surprise—Alabamians are very vocal on these […]

MORE ON Fiscal Policy

Tax Incentives: Not Always the Answer for Alabama’s Economic Struggles

Last month, the state rejoiced with news that Alabama would be the home of a new Toyota-Mazda plant. The plant is expected to bring over 4,000 jobs and billions of dollars in net revenue to the state. With the execution of this deal, known as Project New World, state and local governments will give the two companies […]

API Joins 36 Conservative Groups and Activists: Congress Must Stop New Obamacare Taxes

Lawmakers must act to prevent Obamacare taxes from going into effect next year, 36 conservative groups and activists wrote in a letter addressed to House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.). Absent Congressional action, the Obamacare health insurance tax and medical device tax will both go into effect in 2018. […]

MORE FROM Katherine Green Robertson

The Left’s Energy Policies Generate Energy Poverty

Though the word “poverty” typically provokes thoughts of individuals and families who lack the basic necessities of food, clothing, and shelter, there is another form of material poverty that isn’t as conspicuous, but is nearly as serious: energy poverty.  According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the country’s lowest-income households spend almost one-quarter of their […]

Redemption from Addiction

While scientific research may not definitively prove the causal connection between poverty and addiction (or vice versa), there is an undeniable correlation between the two. Addiction can lead to broken families, neglected children, crime, and incarceration—all of which can serve as chain links in the shackles of poverty. It can be assumed that Alabama’s disproportionately […]

If the People Only Knew

“The people want to vote!”—the most oft-repeated catchphrase of the lottery debate. Even politicians who declare themselves personally opposed to a state-run lottery try to justify their support of it because “the people want to vote.” But politicians know full well that they have not been honest with the people when it comes to a […]